The Sealed Letter, by Emma Donoghue

It’s nice, when the Giller longlist comes out, to find a few books you genuinely like on there — or, a few books you haven’t read yet but know you will like.  Such was my reaction on seeing Emma Donoghue’s latest make the list.  I loved her earlier historical novel, Slammerkin, and while I didn’t love Life Mask quite as much, I certainly found it engaging, so I looked forward to picking up The Sealed Letter.

I absolutely devoured this book. It was a genuine could-not-put-down.  This is some of the best historical fiction — or best fiction of any kind — that I’ve read in a long time.

There are several types of historical fiction, and here on Compulsive Overreader I often promote the “epic” kind — the Margaret George/Sharon Kay Penman/Philippa Gregory genre of big blockbusters based on big stories — the lives of kings, queens and the like.  But another excellent path for the historical fiction writer to take is to tell a “small” story — whether completely fictional or, as in the case of Emma Donoghue’s novels, fictionalized versions of real events — that captures, like a snapshot, the essence of a time and place.

The Sealed Letter is a snapshot of middle-class life in Victorian England, and specifically, of the process of getting a divorce in that era.  Divorce laws had just been liberalized, though they were still draconian by our standards; a woman whose husband petitioned for divorce had a bleak future ahead, with no hope for an income, status in society, or any access to her children.  Such is the fate that awaits Helen Codrington, one of the main characters in this novel.

It was also an era when some women (and men) were beginning to look for new and more just ways to do things, and Helen’s friend Emily “Fido” Faithfull is one such, an early feminist devoted to the cause of women’s rights, though still championing many traditional values.  Those values of home and hearth in their most extreme form are represented in the novel by Helen’s wronged husband Henry.

For someone like me, who often laments the ease and frequency with which people break up marriages these days, it was an eye-opener to get this glimpse into the past and realize how hopeless a woman’s situation was when divorce was much harder to obtain, and the divorce laws heavily biased in favour of the husband.

The boldest move Donoghue makes in this novel is to make Helen an almost completely unlikeable and unsympathetic character. It would have been so much easier to tug on the heartstrings by making her sweet and tragic, but Helen is a hard-hearted little manipulator and the reader (at least, this reader) feels far more sympathy with her husband and with her loyal friend, the aptly named Fido.  Yet even while we recognize that Helen is a selfish schemer, we can’t help seeing that she’s caught in a system that gives her few options.  Surely that’s the true test of injustice — that we can recognize it’s unjust even to people we don’t like or admire.  Helen’s not a nice person, but even she deserves far better choices than the England of 1864 offers to women.

The book is deliciously written, with every word, every description, every turn of phrase suiting the story perfectly.  Emma Donoghue is a perfect example of a writer who is “popular” and eminently readable but also deserves literary acclaim, and I’m glad to see she’s getting it.  So far hers is the only book from the Giller longlist that I’ve read, but I’d be happy to see her win for The Sealed Letter.



Filed under Canadian author, Fiction -- historical

4 responses to “The Sealed Letter, by Emma Donoghue

  1. Those epic stories do have their appeal, but I’m coming to the conclusion that I’m much happier to read the “small story” kind of historical fiction because I don’t spend all my energy fretting about whether the author is telling the real story. I’ve been curious about Donoghue, and this one sounds interesting.

  2. Becky

    I can’t believe that I had never heard of any of these books. I love Historical Fiction books and try to stay on top of what books are the best. I also like to know about great books coming out- for instance I know that Mark Grisham and David Donaldson are coming out with a great book, “Bedlam South,” on October 7th- I was able to get a copy before its release date- I was thrilled! Anyway, I am glad to know about Emma Donoghue’s books. I am definitely going to check them out! Thanks for the tip.

  3. Jenny

    This sounds wonderful! Though, frankly, I’m beginning to think that every book you review sounds wonderful. Maybe it’s you. 🙂

  4. Just read Life Mask over Christmas…I was more enthralled with it in the beginning, then got more disenchanted with it as it went on…I found the politics increasingly tedious (despite the fact that it was an interesting time, politically). I had bought it in the $2 rack at a local used bookstore, drawn in by the pretty cover and what sounded like a good story. But I felt that it disintegrated…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s