Home, by Marilynne Robinson

homeRemember how much I loved Marilynne Robinson’s novel Gilead? Home is not exactly the sequel, but the companion volume to Gilead, brandly-newly released.  And, if possible, I love it more than Gilead.

The story of Home occurs concurrently with the story of Gilead, among the same characters but told from a different point of view that reveals so much more.  The Reverend John Ames, the central character and narrator of Gilead, is a peripheral character in Home, which takes place in the house of his lifelong friend Reverend Robert Boughton. (The two men are aging ministers, Congregationalist and Presbyterian respectively, in the fictional town of Gilead, Iowa in the 1950s). 

As in Gilead, Rev. Boughton’s prodigal son — the one wayward boy among his eight children — Jack Boughton, has come home after twenty years’ absence, and his homecoming unearths old ghosts and raises difficult questions, not least for Jack himself.  Jack Boughton is an utterly compelling character, the kind of man I have tried to write about at least twice but have never gotten close to capturing with such brilliance, warmth and sadness.  He is, in many ways, the main character, but the point of view is that of Glory, another character I found very easy to care about, Jack’s younger sister who has come home, in middle age, to live with her dying father after her own respectable and virtuous life has left her broken and disappointed.  The bond that’s forged between Jack and Glory, and the relationship both of them have with their dying father — a genuinely good Christian man whose lifelong faith is challenged by the return of the son he has always loved, always feared for, and always forgiven — is depicted with such utter candour and perceptiveness it’s breathtaking.

Marilynne Robinson is, quite simply, a writer who makes lesser writers (like me) weep in despair even as we want to sing in triumph for the sheer joy of reading such a book.  Why write at all, knowing that you’ll never be able to write like this? The book is filled with rich, intense detail, so minutely depicted and each note so perfect that it seems every one is necessary to build up this complex, lovely, heartbreaking picture of three people locked in the endless dance that is love and family and the life of faith.

I said when I reviewed Gilead that this is what Christian fiction should be like, and isn’t — brilliantly written literary fiction, the best of anything out there, that also celebrates and explores the Christian faith and how it impacts real lives. Faith and hope and grace (and glory — those being the names of Rev. Boughton’s four daughters) are never easy or cheap in this novel, but they are always absolutely real.

I tried to read this book slowly (which, as you know, is nearly impossible for me), partly because I never wanted it to end, and partly because I was afraid the ending would break my heart.  Sure enough, I didn’t get the resolution I’d hoped for after the end of Gilead, though the ending of Home does take us one tiny step further down the hard road of redemption.  There are no easy, sentimental happy endings with Marilynne Robinson; she leaves the reader to imagine their own ending, with enough hope to believe that grace will, in the end, touch everyone who longs for it. 

There’s no more suspense about what will be the number one book on my Top Ten list for 2008, because there’s no way I will read a better-written, more moving, more beautiful book than Home in the next six weeks. Perhaps I never will again.



Filed under Fiction -- general, Fiction -- inspirational

6 responses to “Home, by Marilynne Robinson

  1. Wow. That’s quite a review.

    I haven’t read either one of them. I guess I should.

  2. You should indeed.

    Next up for me is one of your recommendations: The Lace Reader.

  3. I am a big fan of Gilead (incidentally, did you know Barack Obama lists Gilead as his favourite novel?) and have just begun reading Home. But I have put it down again because I have too many other things going on at the moment and want to be able to enjoy in properly. I will look forward even more to giving it that space after reading your review. Thanks.

  4. I can’t read anything else until I’m done Harry Potter…and while I am enjoying it, it is taking me forever to get through book 6. I keep seeing other books…books that appeal to me more, and call for me to read them. But I’m afraid that if I do, I will never pick Potter up again, or worse, forget everything that has gone on and have to start over on book 1. So I’ll soldier on, and when I am finally finished book seven, I will come to Compulsive Overreader and shop for new books.

  5. Keep on trucking, Jamie, you’ll get there.

    Nathan, since you’re the one who turned me on to Gilead in the first place (and what good taste the US President-Elect has!!), I’m very anxious to hear what you think of Home after you do read it. I’ve seen some reviews compare it unfavourably to Gilead — good book, but not as good — but I enjoyed it even better.

  6. One of the points for discussion in relation to this book is whether it’s as good, better or otherwise than Gilead. And the reason it’s a great point for discussion is that it’s a difficult question.

    One of the aspects of reading Home is that for most of us it happens after reading Gilead. While the books are slightly different in style, reading Home second comes with the experience and expectations brought from the first book. I would be very interested in hearing from anyone who has reading Home as a first experience of Robinson. I suspect Home would still work well as a stand-alone but might be read somewhat differently.

    Robinson’s writing itself is fascinating, so much so that it almost overshadows her admittedly “slow” stories. Yet her characters with their flaws, uncertainties and small redemptions are hauntingly memorable and, though rarely venturing beyond the one old rambling house, Home has a remarkable sense of place—the house itself but in the context of the small community of Gilead, which is always there just beyond the walls.

    These two books should be compulsory reading for any would-be writers—and particularly writers with a bent toward questions of faith. For those who are already Robinson fans, Home is different enough—with sylistic variations and adopting a different perspective and quite different narrative voice, although with some of the same incurably hopeful world-weariness—while giving more of what so captivated them with Gilead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s