Fall On Your Knees by Anne Marie Macdonald ( Canada Reads #1 — NOT a review!)

Fall on Your Knees is the only one of this year’s Canada Reads selections that I’ve already read.  I read it many years ago — more than seven years ago, anyway, because I’ve been blogging my book reviews for the last seven years and I don’ t have it archived.  I could reread it to make my Canada Reads experience complete, but I don’t really want to.

So I should make it clear: this is not a review in the same sense I usually review books here on Compulsive Overreader.  I generally try to review books within a week or two of reading them, so they’re still quite fresh in my mind.  After seven-plus years, a lot of the detail about a book recedes into the background. I forget character names and plot details.  All that lingers, usually, is emotion, a general sense of the feeling the book left with me.

So perhaps I could call this “Fall on Your Knees: what remains.”  I’m just trying to sketch out here what I remember about this book many years after reading, what lingers with me, and why I have no desire to reread it — which is also why I wouldn’t vote for it as the book all Canada should read.

First of all: it is beautifully written.  I do remember that. It’s a breathtaking novel in many ways, and it does have the things I love that many literary novels lack: strong characters and storyline (even though I can’t remember the details of those after so many years).

What I remember most, though, is the general feeling of gloom and depression, despair even, that lingered with  me when I closed the book.  I mean, I do get that a lot of great literary fiction deals with very solemn themes and includes a lot of the dark side of life. But unrelieved darkness, with no sense of hope or joy or triumph of the human spirit — well, I have a problem with that. I don’t demand happy endings but I want endings that leave me with some hope.

One plot point I do remember from this long, sad, beautiful novel is that there is a girl. A very, very Bad Girl. And she wants to sleep with a man, a very, very Good Man. I can’t remember why she has made up her mind to sleep with this good man who has no intention of sleeping with her and is truly dedicated to his wife, but the key thing is: she succeeds. She seduces him.  That part made me so angry, because it’s such a literary cliche (and such a huge piece of reverse sexism) that any woman who sets out to seduce any man will eventually succeed, no matter how good and true he is, even if he’s not attracted to her at all.  I think at that point I might have thrown the book across the room a little.

The only other plot point I remember is that near the end, a character walks from Cape Breton, Nova Scotia, to New York City. Walks.  Which just seemed so unrealistic that it pushed my disbelief past its suspension point, where it fell with a splash in the chilly grey Atlantic.

So, that’s what stays with me years after reading this book.  Beautiful writing, one annoying plot point, one unbelievable plot point, and a general sense of gloom and despair.  And to be fair, there are probably tons of books I read during that same year that I don’t remember even that much about.  At least this one lingered.

But I don’t think it lingered for the right reasons, not for me, anyway.  I know a lot of people really loved this book and it’s a huge favourite with many, but judging it in the harsh light of nearly a decade’s memory, I can’t say I want to reread it or recommend it as the book all Canada should read.

It’s not a fair comparison, of course.  I’ll compare it to four other books I will all have read recently.  What will I remember about Good to a Fault or Generation X seven or eight years from now? Hard to say.  But I think it’s a safe bet that if the main feeling I’m left with after finishing a book is that being human is really not such a great thing at all, I probably won’t be recommending that book to the whole country, or even to my friends.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Canada Reads, Canadian author, Fiction -- historical

2 responses to “Fall On Your Knees by Anne Marie Macdonald ( Canada Reads #1 — NOT a review!)

  1. I found this so interesting (the review — or nonreview — not the book) because I, too, had issues with this novel when I read it years ago. I had to study it for a grad class and I started it thinking I’d enjoy it. Alas, it was not to be. It’s actually on my list of Most Overrated Lit Novels. I was left with an overwhelming impression of its sloppiness when I turned the last page, and I’ve never had any desire to read it again. I wouldn’t recommend this book to anyone either.

    And I really like what you have to say about books that leave us with a negative feeling about being human. Interesting point.

  2. Interesting — I read the same book a little longer ago (I believe it’s been a bit over a decade for me) and while my memory of the the tone matches yours, the details that stuck out for me were quite different. That said, I’m not sure I would read it again, either: it’s just so, relentlessly dark.

    Have you read MacDonald’s subsequent novel, The Way The Crow Flies? I thought it was a beautiful evolution in that it amplified all the strengths of Fall On Your Knees (and it wasn’t without its own darkness), but it had a lot more balance. My review of it is here, if you are interested.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s