A Tale of Two Cities, by Charles Dickens (Second-Chance Books #4)

Tale of Two Cities Book coverSo far, I’m really loving this re-reading the classics project. I’ve always struggled with Dickens. A few years ago I spent an entire summer reading Bleak House, off and on,  and found it … difficult. The only other two Dickens novels I’d read were Great Expectations and A Tale of Two Cities, both decades ago so that I didn’t remember a lot of detail about them. I did have a vague sense that back when I read A Tale of Two Cities, I had a big crush on Sydney Carton, plus it’s one of the shorter Dickens books, so it was the obvious choice for a re-read.

BOY I WAS NOT REMEMBERING WRONG ABOUT THAT CRUSH. Sydney Carton really is one of the great hotties of literature, especially given my love (in a literary sense, not so much in real life) for doomed but charming young men. He’s all that and a bag of chips. Even though I knew how the book ended (not so much from remembering my previous reading of it, as from general cultural awareness), I couldn’t put it down for the last few chapters. I stayed up late, reading and crying.

It’s a beautiful book, very tight and non-rambly by Dickens standards, and very much, of course, an Englishman’s view of the French revolution (and a historical novel even in its time, having been written more than 50 years after the events it describes). It was interesting to read it so soon after Les Miserables, which was written at about the same time, because there’s so much to compare between the two. Both writers share that rambling, discursive style so typical of nineteenth-century novelists (though Dickens far less so than Hugo, at least in these two novels). There’s the French revolutionary setting – one novel by a French writer, writing not about the 1789-92 Revolution but about a later insurrection that’s very much in the shadow of the original one, and the other an English writer trying to capture a sense of what it might have been like for an outsider in Paris during the Reign of Terror. Even some of the characters echo one another: Doctor Manette, though a much less compelling and complex character than Jean Valjean, shares with him a long and unjust imprisonment that gives him trouble readjusting to “real life.” Manette is as completely dependent on the love and support his daughter Lucie as Valjean is on his foster daughter Cosette — with the important difference that Lucie knows about her father’s imprisonment whereas Cosette is completely in the dark. Both girls, however, are idealized images of beautiful and perfect young womanhood — good, virtuous, selfless, golden-haired, lovely and just a little, um, dull.  And each is loved devoted by a young man who’s not terribly interesting either, though Marius Pontmercy at least has the saving grace of being a bit more complex and a bit less virtuous than Charles Darnay, who is little more than The Good Guy.

In each story, too, the most interesting character is the one who’s in the throes of unrequited love. And despite my long-term affection for Eponine in Les Mis  (more in the musical than in the novel, actually) I have to admit that Sydney Carton is the undisputed king of Unrequited Lovers, because he sacrifices himself, not just to save Lucie, which would be impressive enough, but to save Charles Darnay because Lucie loves him. Now, that’s pure gold. And after 150+ years, it hasn’t gotten old.

Should I attempt another Dickens novel? I won’t read Bleak House again — you can’t make me — but maybe Dickens fans out there can suggest one I haven’t read that might charm me. A sort of “If you liked A Tale of Two Cities, you might like …” kind of recommendation? What have you got for me?

ADDENDUM: After I posted this, my dad read it and sent me this cartoon, which he describes as his favourite from his days working in the publishing business:





Filed under Fiction -- historical

8 responses to “A Tale of Two Cities, by Charles Dickens (Second-Chance Books #4)

  1. Glad you enjoyed this one — it’s my favorite. 🙂 If the “tight and non-rambly” Dickens is your cup of tea, I recommend “Great Expectations” or “Oliver Twist.” Or perhaps “Hard Times.”

    • I have definitely read Great Expectations but there’s nothing that lingers in my mind to make me think I want to reread it. I may have read Oliver Twist, or I could just be thinking about seeing the musical. I’m not that concerned about “tight and non-rambly” — I’ve reread Les Miserables and next on my list is Anna Karenina so I’m not scared to tackle long books.

      I’m actually thinking of David Copperfield, which I started once but could get into. What do you think?

  2. Kudos for trying a book like this again. I love the idea of giving books a second chance, because so many times in my life I simply haven’t been in the right place to enjoy certain novels. Dickens is a great example of that. I’ve been thinking of re-reading Great Expectations, but I don’t think I can make it through A Tale of Two Cities again.

  3. I love Tale of Two Cities and Great Expectations so deeply since first reading them in 9th grade that I’ve considered Dickens my favorite author for most of my life. I’ve reread both these books more times than I can count. There are others of his that I love (I think Hard Times was one) and others I can’t quite get through. I would for sure have to say GE. Also, its not Dickens, but have you read Kristen Lavernsdatter? You simply must, if you haven’t.

  4. Just read the comments so I should say that David Copperfield was one of the ones even I (a hard core Dickens fan) could not get through. But as others comments, perhaps that was just timing and to each her own. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s